This Photo makes me a Criminal!

gart4-leica-003

This is the tower of the Railway Station in Luxembourg City, a historical building.

The tower is the main subject of the photograph, there’s no one making silly poses in front of it, it’s no stupid selfie…. and this picture, presented on my humble blog is outlawed here in Luxembourg!

But it’s not only photography of this tower that’s outlawed. You have no right to use photographs of any public buildings, where the building is the subject, and publish it unless you have the authorisation of the architect, his heirs or right holders or the owner if ever the architect is dead over 70 years, and mostly if you pay your dues to them!

Here’s an article (in french) detailing this crap: http://www.lessentiel.lu/fr/luxembourg/story/Attention-si-vous-prenez-en-photo-un-b-timent-21753405

So now I’m a really bad criminal!

Great, Luxembourg. I love those absolutely stupid laws. I love how European countries like Luxembourg are actively killing photography!

Unless you are a licensed photographer, paying your dues to the architect or other, you have no business creating something, even if the buildings are supposedly PUBLIC!

Some time ago, tourists have been intercepted by security personnel of the public baths in Luxembourg / Kirchberg. They were forbidden to take pictures of the fairly recent and admittedly very photogenic building.

Now mix this with restrictions about photographing people or cars an main subject in the streets (yes, cars too as this violates the privacy of the drivers!) and what have we left?

This:

160520-kodak-tri-x-canon-a-1-017

img_0096

img_0569

161206-ricoh-gr1-ilford-hp5-30

img_0399

Thank you, Luxembourg, my country!

Guess I’ll start converting to landscape photography….. unless the forests are protected too.

Feeling depressed!

Thanks for reading!

 

Advertisements

16 thoughts on “This Photo makes me a Criminal!

  1. It is not (yet) so bad in Germany but you can get into legal trouble when photographing people. To be really safe, and I am being sarcastic here, it is better only to take pictures of tourists or to make sure that those people in a picture are one of many and therefore extras (“Beiwerk”).

    At the end of the day, stupid laws are going to rescinded if ignored by the population at large.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. does this mean you can photograph private dwellings and parked cars as long as they are empty? Maybe pets? How about sections of buildings, not showing the whole building? Just trying to think out of the box if it helps you to continue providing us with great photos Frank.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. ItÂŽs just ok for people to get surveyed every day by CCTV, through Smartphones, a Smart Home, ob FB, Twitter etc., but if someone is making a picture in a public space to create something artistically, theyÂŽre freaking out because of “their personal rights”. ItÂŽs just ridiculous! Great post!!!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Moien HĂ€r Lehnen,
    MÀin Englesch ass nit sou gutt, dofir schreiwen ech léiwer op Lëtzebuergesch.
    Ech sin e grousse Fan vun Äerer SĂ€it, well ech selwer och nach analog fotografĂ©ieren, hun virun 2 JoĂ«r och digital ugefaangen awer gemierkt dass dat Menges nĂ€ischt ass, ech si nach ee Fotograf vum aale Schlag (hun 53 JoĂ«r).
    Dass mir eis hei zu Lëtzebuerg schëlleg maache wa mer öffentlech Gebaier fotograféieren an déi Fotoen publizéieren hun ech awer och nit gewosst, ech hun och schon bei Fotosaustellungen a Concouren matgemeet, mee war mer nie bewosst dass dat ee kriminellen Akt ass!(Am Zesummenhang mam entsprechende Gesetz).
    Hei zu LĂ«tzebuerg get wirklich emmer eng eejen Zöppchen gekacht, an alles probĂ©iert fir engem d’Liewen z’erschwĂ©ieren an ze versauen!

    Vive de Grand-Duché!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Richteg, Vive LĂ«tzebuerg! Wann se wirklech dei Gesetzer duerchsĂ€tzen dann hun mir et e besse schweier hei! Zum GlĂ«ck get nach net ze vill do kontrolleiert, waat awer mat der aktueller ‘Terrorsituatioun’ keint seier Ă€nneren.

      Mee all Iwwerwaachungskamera’en gin kommentarlos akzepteiert! Komesch!!

      Hun iwwregens och 53 Joer…. as wuel de Grond fir Film!

      Komesch, freier war awer alles besser……

      Like

  5. Merci fir Äer schĂ©i Wierder, an dass frĂ©ier Villes besser war, mierken ech all Dag mĂ©i! Och an der analoger Fotografie hun ech den Androck dass sech emmer mĂ©i Leit erem fir dĂ©i Fotografie intressĂ©ieren, ech hu mer och schon bal all Link op Äerem Site ugekuckt a war erstaunt wĂ©ivill nach analog fotografĂ©iert get :-)!
    Ech fille lo nit mĂ©i sou als “Ewiggestrigen” wĂ©i ech oft vu mengen digitalen FotosfrĂ«nn genannt gin!

    Léif Gréiss an e schéine Weekend.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. This is shame. Takes people’s rights/liberties.

    Anyway, here people seem to be more protective of their property/houses – I would get more trouble shooting private houses compared to people photos.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s